Is Obama’s Executive Order “Unconstitutional?”

Associate Justice Robert Jackson (1941-1954

Associate Justice Robert Jackson (1941-1954

I realize that as a Conservative Talk Radio Chat Show Host I am supposed to be screaming about the “unconstitutional” actions that President Obama is about to take in issuing an Executive Order on Immigration. Now I agree that the Presidents action would be ill-advised, wrong, and divisive instead of unifying. I also agree that he would be flying in the face of the electorate who clearly do not want such an Executive Order to be issued.

But does that make it “unconstitutional?”

The Court ruled some years ago (Youngstown Steel & Tube v Sawyer), and indeed, Justice Robert Jackson, created a test to determine if an Executive Order is outside the bounds of the Constitution. It goes like this:

  • Best case – Did Congress specifically allow the action to be taken by the President? (Think Authorization of Force, or War Powers Act). If Congress allowed the action to be taken, then the Executive Order is Constitutional.

Now Consider this line of debate: In 1781, Congress specifically formed the Department of the Treasury, under the Executive Branch. In 1891, Congress decided that the Federal Government would now oversee Immigration and thus specifically established a Commissioner of Immigration in the Treasury Department, and in 1933, moved that Commissioner to a new Department of Immigration and Naturalization that answered to the President as a cabinet member. Later INS would become ICE, but remain under the Executive as specifically assigned by Congress. So… did the Congress tell the President – any President – to oversee matters of Immigration? One would have to argue that both Reagan and Bush saw that as the case when they each issued Executive Orders dealing with Immigration issues.

  • The Middle Case – Is it “unclear” as to which branch of the Government has the authority to act on the given issue?

Again, the Constitution says (Article 1, Section 8, Cause 4) that Congress “shall have the power to establish an uniform rule on Naturalization.” So did Congress exercise that power by establishing the Departments listed above?

  • Worst Case – Has Congress Specifically Said “NO” to the Executive Action?

Well… has Congress voted to stop the President from carrying out the Executive Order? Speaker Boehner has said it would “poison the well,” but that is not a Congressional vote to say “No.”

So given those facts, and the long history of Executive action by Presidents from Washington to Obama, can one actually say that the proposed Order is “unConstitutional?”

Now again, I am NOT arguing the “rightness” of the order. Again, I think that it is a bad idea and it is little more than playing politics with immigration. But is it “unconstitutional?”

Based on precedent, probably not.

Advertisements

About Dave

Talk Show host, lifelong Baseball and Star Trek fan, US Navy Submariner and Fire Control Technician (Ballistic Missile) 1st Class Petty Officer (Submarine Qualified), Dave is married with four daughters, one son, two sons-in-law and two grandchildren plus one on the way. He resides quietly in Manteca, CA, where he records his podcast, Plausibly Live, three days a week. He also writes for several other blogs and as a "Stay at home Dad" plays a lot of games with his son. Dave loves books, history and is learning to weld and drive a forklift. Just for fun. Dave is also a Life Member of the Disabled American Veterans and a Member of the US Submarine Veterans.

Posted on November 18, 2014, in Art 1 Sect 8, Article 1, Naturalization and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: